some thoughts about Robert Robinson:
I had seen references to Robert Robinson over the years, and wondered why nothing was written about him in the land of his birth.
I assumed at first that he was a Communist, or a fellow traveller, given the period when he went to Russia, and that he would therefore be favouably viewed by the Left.
When I began to read excerpts from his book Black on Red, I realised that he had no idealogical preference for the U.S.S.R. He was only doing what Jamaicans have always done - looking for a better job, more education and a better way of life. He was also apparently, like many Jamaicans, a devoted Christian.
Clearly he could never be a poster boy for the Left!
When he hoped to return to Jamaica in the 1950s it was probably the fear that he was a left-wing activist that prevented his return. In the '70s, when he did in fact return briefly to Jamaica at the invitation of Dudley Thompson, the Foreign Affairs minister, he was still refused a Jamaican passport. He believed that the reason was still the fear of his supposed Communist sympathies; in fact it is far more likely that the Soviet-sympathising PNP government at that period perceived him as likely to portray Russia in an unfavourable light, and so prove hostile to their current policies. Interestingly I have so far failed to find any references to his presence in Jamaica in 1976-7 in the Jamaican press. (I'm still looking.)
I had read long ago about a Black Jamaican who was a member of the Moscow Soviet back in the 1930s. I assumed that he was in the same catagory as Claude McKay and others who had gone to Russia for idealogical reasons. Last year I was able to follow up Robert N Robinson's story, online, and then by reading his remarkable autobiography Black on Red. His story is a very different one - he had no particular Communist leanings - he just wanted a better job and better pay than a Black worker could get in the USA in the Depression years of the 1930s.
As a result of this very natural ambition he found himself trapped in the USSR for over 40 years, surviving Stalinist purges, World War II and the attentions of the various incarnations of the Soviet secret police. If ever a book made clear the oppressive nature of the Soviet regime, this one does. It was a major triumph of the human spirit that Robert Robinson emerged at the end of his Russian exile a whole and sane person. It is clear that his religious faith was an important factor in that survival.
I'm not sure how great a claim Jamaica really has to this remarkable man. He was born here, but his mother was from Dominica. She and his Jamaican father migrated to Cuba, and when Robert was about 6 years old, his father deserted him and his mother. So it was his Dominican mother, Octavia, who gave him his sound upbringing, in spite of her own dire circumstances which led her to the brink of suicide. There was an innate soundness of character backing up that early training.
Robinson twice attempted to get back to Jamaica. In the 1950s the problem was that the Norman Manley government was having its own problems with Leftist rebels and had no interest in allowing back a returning resident from Russia, whose political intentions were an unknown quantity. In the 1970s the problem was presumably the reverse. The Michael Manley government had moved well to the left, and must have been very sceptical about the views of the Soviets which might be expressed by someone who had 'escaped' from a 40+ year virtual 'imprisonment' in the Soviet state. That story still needs to be unravelled.
There is also a great irony in the fact that the agent of Robinson's release from Russia, was Idi Amin!
As a result of this very natural ambition he found himself trapped in the USSR for over 40 years, surviving Stalinist purges, World War II and the attentions of the various incarnations of the Soviet secret police. If ever a book made clear the oppressive nature of the Soviet regime, this one does. It was a major triumph of the human spirit that Robert Robinson emerged at the end of his Russian exile a whole and sane person. It is clear that his religious faith was an important factor in that survival.
I'm not sure how great a claim Jamaica really has to this remarkable man. He was born here, but his mother was from Dominica. She and his Jamaican father migrated to Cuba, and when Robert was about 6 years old, his father deserted him and his mother. So it was his Dominican mother, Octavia, who gave him his sound upbringing, in spite of her own dire circumstances which led her to the brink of suicide. There was an innate soundness of character backing up that early training.
Robinson twice attempted to get back to Jamaica. In the 1950s the problem was that the Norman Manley government was having its own problems with Leftist rebels and had no interest in allowing back a returning resident from Russia, whose political intentions were an unknown quantity. In the 1970s the problem was presumably the reverse. The Michael Manley government had moved well to the left, and must have been very sceptical about the views of the Soviets which might be expressed by someone who had 'escaped' from a 40+ year virtual 'imprisonment' in the Soviet state. That story still needs to be unravelled.
There is also a great irony in the fact that the agent of Robinson's release from Russia, was Idi Amin!
other people's comments -
I wish I could speak to Robert Robinson and shake his hand and I wish there was something that someone could do to give him back the years that the Soviet system took from him. I truly wish the book would have been bigger. I wish all of Robert Robinson's memoirs were available to read. Don't wait another minute-----READ THIS BOOK!
from a reader's comments on Amazon
There is one book on my list which is an actual account of a black man's life in Russia. Robert Robinson was a trained machinist from Detroit who answered Russia's call of volunteers during the 30s. He had faced nothing but closed doors in his own country. His bio presents the realism of political and human fear under the Stalin communists. I had a romantic view of communism, and I needed Robert Robinson's experiences to counter it.
online comment
from a reader's comments on Amazon
There is one book on my list which is an actual account of a black man's life in Russia. Robert Robinson was a trained machinist from Detroit who answered Russia's call of volunteers during the 30s. He had faced nothing but closed doors in his own country. His bio presents the realism of political and human fear under the Stalin communists. I had a romantic view of communism, and I needed Robert Robinson's experiences to counter it.
online comment